Defending Pilate & Judas

Someone remarked to me the other day that he had heard several sermons over the years stating that Pontius Pilate and Judas are condemned to burn eternally in hell for their role in Jesus’ crucifixion. I stared at him for a moment and said, “That’s absurd.”

Blaming Pilate, or Judas, for Christ’s crucifixion takes the blame out of our own hands. Because here is the bitter truth: you put Him there. I put Him there. Even as nice as we can be, as perfect as we strive to become, as few commandments as we break… we are still nowhere near worthy of approaching the throne of God. Even though we are saved through Christ, we are still sinners. That will not change until we are dead and beyond this fallen world. Pilate is not to blame. Judas is not to blame. God permitted them to play a role, along with the Sanhedrin and Herod, but neither of them is condemned to hell for it.

There is only one sin that cannot be forgiven, and that is rejection of the Holy Spirit – that is, denial of Christ. Judas causing Jesus to be arrested was not that denial. In fact, it may have even turned out radically different from what he wanted. We know nothing of the motivations of Judas, only of his betrayal. Was it truly for financial gain, or did Judas want Jesus to become the Messiah, and thought that by having him arrested, it would force Jesus to claim leadership over the Jews? We will never know. But we do know that if Judas repented before killing himself, he was not condemned to hell.

How is Pilate even in the wrong? He did not want to condemn Jesus. He gave the crowd multiple chances to change their mind. He ordered Jesus flogged hoping it would satisfy their bloodlust. And when faced with no other choice but to avoid a riot, he “washed his hands” of Jesus’ death. Part of this may have been his wife’s warning not to be involved. Part of it might have been that he knew Jesus was innocent. Pilate was brutal, unforgiving, and not known for his mercy. But he wanted to spare the Messiah. If he acknowledged Jesus as “more than a man,” is that not an indication of a changed heart? Pilate’s story did not end there. In scripture, it did, but what became of him? Many ancient rumors involve him in the early Christian church. Is it possible that Pilate was so changed that day that he did become saved? If so, he is most certainly not burning in hell for all eternity.

Claiming that God ordains events and then condemns those who participate in them to hell is unfair of God. Yes, God ordains events… but He allows us to participate in them according to the nature of our own sins, not because He has “made” us involved. God used Judas’ greed (or ambition?) but it did not have to be Judas. God also used a brutal governor at risk by being sanctioned by Rome, but it did not have to be Pilate. Is the Centurion who nailed Christ to the cross and then professed later, “Truly, He must have been the son of God!” condemned because his hands drove in the nails?

Even closer to home… are any of these men worse than we are? Just because we were not in the crowd, or sitting on the governor’s seat, or kissed Him in the garden does not mean it was not our fault. It was, is, and always will be our fault. But because He did it, none of us are condemned.

4 Replies to “Defending Pilate & Judas”

  1. Interesting post! I have heard the same things said about Judas and Pontius Pilate in a church that I used to attend. It always didn’t sit well with me that people did not address the fact that the Bible never gave a full account of their lives. I would have thought this especially obvious in the case of Pontius. Granted, I haven’t researched Judas enough to be *as* confident in his defense, but I agree that people have the opportunity to repent, and that is something that we ought be more mindful of with any Biblical figure.
    Perhaps Pontius and Judas are in hell.
    Perhaps not.
    But let *us* not do the condemning.

    1. I think it’s sad that people condemn their actions and don’t realize that in the eyes of God, our actions are just as bad. Rebellion. Jealousy. Lust. Maybe we didn’t sign Jesus over for some pieces of silver, but we sell Him out every day through our sinful desires and actions. Being condemning of them is denying our role in nailing Jesus to the cross.

Share Your Thoughts

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s